QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

#49ers Brock Purdy got his entire offensive line brand new Toyota's 🤯pic.twitter.com/8U9zLBYIjv

— ???????????????????????????????????????????? (@TheSFNiners) December 20, 2024

That's my QB1

He got Jake Brendel a 1996 Toyota Corolla.

HA

He got him the turbo engine so he can gtfo of town asap!

I think that was pretty amazing. Putting skills aside for sake of discussion, everything else about this guy reeks 9ers. He's the perfect fit and hope it all works out long term.

Originally posted by ubaisore:
I am really floored by the sheer lack of realistic discussion in this thread. He is a very good quarterback and there is no QB that is taking scrubs to the superbowl. Every "great" QB also had a lot of other things that helped him. We have one that can bring us to the promised land. Lets not ignore the market and start looking for another. SMDH

Logical post.

Originally posted by A-R-S:

Lol, the cost of 5 new Sequoia's is more than his entire take-home comp this year.

He gets paid a ton in endorsements from John Deere, Ariat, and Toyota. Had that applebees commercial too lol. He probably got special deals on those vehicles, due to his connection.

So, I'm sure he had enough to buy em.

Originally posted by OnTheClock:

Originally posted by A-R-S:
Lol, the cost of 5 new Sequoia's is more than his entire take-home comp this year.

He gets paid a ton in endorsements from John Deere, Ariat, and Toyota. Had that applebees commercial too lol. He probably got special deals on those vehicles, due to his connection.

So, I'm sure he had enough to buy em.

His new contract will be enough to buy several dealerships if he wants.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Statpaddy Mahomes is 4th all time in postseason YPA, with a season's worth of games played. He's the leader in passer rating.

Not only is this a stupid argument, but you contradict yourself with your conclusions. Big oof FootballNovice.

He's 17th.

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS3cgpWvJDjoCdU48i7dv1OuY1aEqiJkbKKKw&s

Brock is ahead of him.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Oh f**k off with that nonsense, Brock was struggling before missing a game vs GB. He's never had a plus arm, that's no even debatable.

your whole debate is based around one of the worst stats for a QB.

Again yards per attempt does not factor in YAC. Brock throws CMC a screen that goes for 30 yards. it's a 30 yard pass and inflates his Y/A. If you were an expert you'd know that.

You want to use stats, look at his IAY in 2023 which was 8.2 yards, which was 6th overall and tied with Desmond Ritter and Trevor Lawrence.

On please explain to me how condensed splits work and how that doesn't lead to him having favorable matchups downfield lol.

I didn't love Lance, I didn't want Mac Jones. I wanted fields and I wanted to see Lance actually get meaningful playing time and develop. I bet you loved Tim Tebow.

In one ear, out the other.

Brock has had an injury since the Vikings game, and it's only gotten worse since then. This is noticeable to anybody who actually watches things and knows how to think. Compare the way the ball came out of his hand vs. the Jets to how it has come out since then. Against the Jets, he was throwing tight spirals with good revs. Since the Chiefs game in particular, he has been throwing wobblers.

Against the Patriots, he was still able to throw 50 yards in the air to Screenbo without having to exert too much effort. Against the Bears, he only managed to get it 40 yards to Jennings (significantly underthrown despite the completion) despite putting everything he had in the throw.

In 2023, every Brock deep miss was OVERTHROWN. This year, every miss, except for a slightly overthrown ball to Aiyuk vs. the Rams, has been underthrown.

Calling yards per attempt "one of the worst stats for a QB" is laughable. It's literally the best stat for a QB. You can't evaluate QBs solely based on stats, anyway, since stats just aren't reliable in football, but it's the top stat you look at to get a sense of how a QB is performing.

You start with the team's points to see if a QB even qualifies for having played well. Stat Paddy doesn't even qualify since the Chiefs have had average scoring the last 2 seasons.

Brock doesn't qualify THIS season (because he's been injured), but he sure as s**t did last year.

Then you go to yards per attempt (actually, net yards per attempt is better, since it factors in sacks and sack yards), then look at the QB's yards (or net yards) to make sure the yards per attempt corresponds to enough actual production. Then you look at turnovers, since those affect the defense.

I'm sure you think Blake Bortles was great in 2015, though. 4400 yards and 35 TDs.

Brock was 2nd in air yards per completion last year, so the "YAC" (it should be RAC, YAC is supposed to be yards after contact) is a meaningless argument. Also, you don't just automatically discount the QB's role in generating RAC. In Stat Paddy's case, you do, since he gets it from throwing screens, but in Brock's case, he was hitting guys perfectly in stride on digs.

Condensed splits means your "teams were DARING Brock to throw it downfield" is total nonsense. Also, most of Brock's success throwing down field came out of either empty gun or in shotgun with CMC not even on the field. All the excuses for Brock's downfield success come from the land of fairy tale narratives such as, "this wide receiver is producing because the other WR is drawing double coverage," "this declining WR who isn't producing anymore is struggling because teams are double covering him. We need a WR opposite him so teams can't double cover him," "this defensive lineman who isn't producing anymore is struggling because he's being double teamed," "this QB is struggling because of his offensive line," and other make-believe nonsense that has never been true for any player, ever.

Trey Lance didn't deserve meaningful playing time. He is nowhere near as talented as Brock. He is not only horrible in every aspect of the position that actually matters, but he's horrible in the aspects that novice fans think matter. He's slow as molasses (ran in the 4.9s at the freshman combine and gets walked down by linebackers trying to get to the boundary) and has mediocre arm strength (then again, considering he can't even throw a spiral, maybe his arm strength is better than it seems).

I won't be shocked if we hear after the season that Brock played with a partially torn labrum or some injury like that. Hopefully he won't require surgery.

Purdy's greatest strength is what he has between his ears. He is a good reader of the game and a good planner. I am not sure that any quarterback could have done much better this season, though, with the injuries on the O line, at wide receiver and at running back. Quality guy with a great future.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I won't be shocked if we hear after the season that Brock played with a partially torn labrum or some injury like that. Hopefully he won't require surgery.

Is he on the injury report?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
A 3 year $75 million contract would be very fair. It gives him a shot to keep his job based on the success he had in his first 2 seasons yet also does not bench him for his poor regression this year.

Oh stop it. Carr got 4 yrs $150M. baker got 3yrs $100M. He's gonna get that much and regardless of what we all think, he's gonna get more than that.

This! Despite all the hope in this thread, Brock is not taking a discount. He's gonna try and get as much as he can.

Originally posted by swoosh6996:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
A 3 year $75 million contract would be very fair. It gives him a shot to keep his job based on the success he had in his first 2 seasons yet also does not bench him for his poor regression this year.

Oh stop it. Carr got 4 yrs $150M. baker got 3yrs $100M. He's gonna get that much and regardless of what we all think, he's gonna get more than that.

This! Despite all the hope in this thread, Brock is not taking a discount. He's gonna try and get as much as he can.

It's pretty much his only shot he going to get to be in a situation like this. We all would try

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I won't be shocked if we hear after the season that Brock played with a partially torn labrum or some injury like that. Hopefully he won't require surgery.

Is he on the injury report?

better keep this one on the qt so goodell doesn't find out

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by swoosh6996:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
A 3 year $75 million contract would be very fair. It gives him a shot to keep his job based on the success he had in his first 2 seasons yet also does not bench him for his poor regression this year.

Oh stop it. Carr got 4 yrs $150M. baker got 3yrs $100M. He's gonna get that much and regardless of what we all think, he's gonna get more than that.

This! Despite all the hope in this thread, Brock is not taking a discount. He's gonna try and get as much as he can.

It's pretty much his only shot he going to get to be in a situation like this. We all would try

Exactly! This may be his only shot at a huge payday. And with all the money Jed has been doling out, you know Purdy's agent is gonna make sure that his guy gets his cut when it's his turn in a couple months.

Originally posted by Niner4ever:
Really like Purdy but there are options to giving him the bag. Just like everyone I want this team to close it out so I'd consider:

3-4 first round picks for Burrow, though the Brown family might rather have him retire than give in to his demands.

2 first round picks for Trevor Lawrence, needs to be a better passer but he doesn't have any real weapons.

Soothing Rodgers personality for 1 year, until Adams arrived no real threats, with a bad O-line, it's the Jets need not say more.

LMAOOOOOOO

I'd rather give Brock $75M a year than trade 2 first round picks for Lawrence and his contract.

You can't be serious.